Independent Retailers’ Confidence Climbs as Holiday Shopping Commences

Written by Rob Stott

November 3, 2020

Halloween is behind us, which means all sights are set squarely on these final two months of the year — arguably two of the most important months on the retail calendar. Holiday shopping season is in full swing now, and given the way the rest of 2020 has panned out, there is quite a lot riding on these final few weeks for Independent retailers across the country. But if Nationwide Marketing Group’s Independent Retail Confidence Index has anything to say about it, the channel — and perhaps more specifically, Nationwide dealers — are ready for this final push at retail.

The NMG Index nudged up nearly two points in November to 194.095 (up from 192.2), setting a new high for the four-month-old survey. Percentage-wise, the NMG Index rose roughly half a point to 69.1%.

Much of the boost in confidence, according to retailers’ responses, has to do with strong customer demand that has remained high for several months — in some cases despite there being a lack of promotional activity. The strong demand, though, is still being met with inventory struggles as many retailers still report not being able to get their hands on product to help meet the demand, a sign that manufacturers are still struggling to catch up on orders in the wake of the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic.

Another big uncertain for retailers during this survey cycle was the election. With responses gathered during the final two weeks of October, many dealers reported a “cloudy” future and uncertainty over what the economy will look like — and how it will respond — after the election.

“I have a degree of uncertainty related to the upcoming election,” one retailer responded. “In addition, it is hard to know for certain if the government will in fact enact an additional stimulus bill. I hope after November 3rd there’s some clarity as to future economics. Until then and possibly after it is hard to forecast or elevate confidence above hopeful.”

Despite the seeming uneasiness of the elevated confidence level, retailers are continuing to see strong returns in actual sales performance. In September, 85% of responding retailers hit or exceeded their sales goal for that month, a one-point increase over the previous month’s survey.

Traffic Patterns

An interesting note in the November NMG Index survey comes in the form of retailers’ confidence in the types of traffic they’ll be able to drive and convert into sales. Over the course of the first four months of the NMG Index, foot traffic has outpaced online traffic by nearly two points. That remained true for November, but the gap actually increased slightly with foot traffic achieving a new high of 7.35 (out of 10) and online traffic falling to 5.74.

A decline in November, even an ever-so-slight one, is the data point of note here. It’s statistically almost irrelevant, but a decline during a month in which Adobe Analytics predicts record online spending gives pause. With a massive opportunity to drive online sales during the height of the holiday shopping season should, in theory, cause retailers’ confidence to spike in that regard, but that’s not reflected in the NMG Index.

Prospering Products

The collection of 18 product categories that the NMG Index surveys for had their most prosperous month in November. Taking all 18 scores, the products registered an average score of 6.83 (out of 10), which is the highest score in the four months of the NMG Index. Further, looking at the month-over-month trends, 13 of the 18 product categories checked in with higher scores in November, and another eight of the categories had their strongest performing months on record.

Most notably, Connected Services have come on strong since the early NMG Index surveys, increasing by nearly two full points since its September low. The growth can certainly be attributed to popular device launches during this time of year with Apple, Google and Samsung all introducing new product during the last quarter.

Connect With Us!

More Podcasts

159: EPA’s Dan Cronin Talks Earth Day, ENERGY STAR and More

159: EPA’s Dan Cronin Talks Earth Day, ENERGY STAR and More

Ahead of Earth Day 2023, we sat down with Dan Cronin, program manager for ENERGY STAR at the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to talk about the program’s impact, the Inflation Reduction Act and much more.

158: Getting Seriously Small Town with Sorenson’s Appliance & TV

158: Getting Seriously Small Town with Sorenson’s Appliance & TV

Geneva, Minnesota is town of just over 500 residents, and it also happens to be the home of Nationwide Marketing Group Member Sorenson’s Appliance & TV. Co-owner Dak Sorenson and his team have found success by leaning heavily into that small-town mindset in every aspect of the business.

157: Independent Retail Through the Eyes of a Nationwide Member Support Manager

157: Independent Retail Through the Eyes of a Nationwide Member Support Manager

Brett Kelley joined the Nationwide Marketing Group team roughly one year ago as a Member Support Manager — the team that sits on the front lines of the independent retail channel, engaging with our Members and helping them thrive on their own terms. As such, he (and the full MSM team) has a very unique perspective into what life is like as an independent retailer. We tap into that experience and more.